Medicaid vs. Obamacare: Costs, Benefits and Enrollment

Obamacare, formally known as the Affordable Care Act (ACA), is the federal law that created health insurance marketplaces and expanded protections. Meanwhile, Medicaid is a government-run health insurance program for people with low incomes or certain qualifying conditions. They overlap in a few ways, especially after the ACA’s Medicaid expansion, but each has its own eligibility rules, benefits, and cost structure. 

A financial advisor can help align your health coverage choice with your broader financial plan and transitions like retirement or income changes.

What Is Obamacare?

Obamacare is shorthand for the Affordable Care Act, a sweeping law passed in 2010 that restructured many parts of U.S. health insurance markets. One of its central features is the health insurance Marketplace, sometimes called the “exchange,” where individuals and families can shop for qualified health plans. Private insurers that offer these plans must comply with ACA standards (for example, covering essential health benefits and prohibiting denial for preexisting conditions).

To make coverage more affordable, the ACA provides premium tax credits for people whose incomes are within certain limits. These subsidies reduce monthly premiums so enrollees pay less of the cost out of pocket. For those in the lower-income ranges, cost-sharing reductions further reduce deductibles, copays, and out-of-pocket maximums if they enroll in a Silver-level plan.

Also, the ACA gave states the option to expand Medicaid eligibility. In states that adopted expansion, many low-income adults are moved to Medicaid so eligibility under Obamacare may begin where Medicaid leaves off.

Recent policy shifts have affected how subsidies and access work. Some enhanced premium credits introduced during the COVID era have been extended, but debates and legislation propose altering them again, which could impact the cost advantage of marketplace plans.

What Is Medicaid?

Medicaid is a joint federal and state program that provides health coverage for people with limited income or particular needs (e.g. children, pregnant women, disabled individuals, elderly). Each state runs its own Medicaid program within federal guidelines, so eligibility and services can differ significantly across states.

Under the ACA’s Medicaid expansion option, states agreed to cover adults with incomes up to 138% of the federal poverty level (FPL), which works out to roughly $21,600 for a single individual in many states. In states that adopted expansion, income alone often determines eligibility (so long as the individual meets citizenship or residency criteria).

However, not all states expanded Medicaid, due to a 2012 Supreme Court ruling that made expansion optional. In non-expansion states, eligibility remains more restrictive, often limited to children, pregnant women, the disabled, or parental caregivers. Many low-income adults fall into a “coverage gap” with incomes too high for Medicaid yet too low to receive subsidy support for marketplace plans.

Medicaid’s cost structure is relatively favorable: many enrollees pay little or nothing in premiums, and out-of-pocket costs are usually minimal. States may impose modest cost-sharing, but federal rules cap total spending on premiums and cost-sharing at 5% of family income for most expansion populations.

Some states use Section 1115 waivers to experiment with premium or cost-sharing conditions for certain enrollees, though they cannot waive core protections like cost limits.

Medicaid services low-income Americans so it tends to offer broad coverage with fewer financial barriers for many essential services. But recipient access depends heavily on state-level policies, provider participation, and budget decisions.

Eligibility Differences and Who Qualifies

Obamacare Eligibility

To enroll in a marketplace (Obamacare) plan, you must generally:

• Be a U.S. citizen or lawfully present resident (and not incarcerated)
• Live in the state that offers the plan
• Not have access to affordable, minimum essential employer coverage
• Not be eligible for Medicare or in many cases Medicaid

Your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is key in determining subsidy eligibility. MAGI is based on AGI plus certain tax-exempt income (e.g. tax-exempt interest) while excluding Social Security benefits.

Obamacare subsidies are available to people with incomes from roughly 100% of FPL up through certain higher income levels. If a state expanded Medicaid then eligibility for marketplace subsidies begins above the Medicaid threshold.

Medicaid Eligibility

Medicaid eligibility depends heavily on state rules and beneficiary categories. In expansion states, many adults with income under 138% of FPL qualify based purely on income.

In non-expansion states, adults without children often cannot qualify, even at very low incomes. That means a healthy, low-income adult might be left out entirely. 

For categories like children, disabled individuals, seniors or pregnant women, both income and asset limits may apply.

One evolving factor is recent legislation proposals that could impose new verification, work or reporting requirements for Medicaid enrollees, potentially reducing eligibility or increasing administrative burden.

Medicaid and marketplace eligibility may overlap in states that expanded Medicaid, so they typically route individuals to Medicaid if they qualify based on income, thus preventing double coverage.

Enrollment Windows & Timing Differences

One of the biggest practical differences between Medicaid and marketplace coverage is when and how you can enroll.

For ACA marketplace plans, enrollment is generally limited to a once-a-year open enrollment period (often November through mid-January). Outside that window, you usually need a qualifying life event (e.g. marriage, birth, loss of other coverage) to trigger a Special Enrollment Period (SEP). Coverage typically begins on January 1 if enrolled early, or the first day of the next month after enrollment if later in the period.

In contrast, Medicaid enrollment is year-round, with coverage beginning immediately, or even retroactively in many states for medical services received before enrollment, so long as eligibility is met.

When you apply via the marketplace, the system will often screen for Medicaid eligibility. If you qualify for Medicaid, the exchange process may forward your application to the state Medicaid program. 

One challenge of certain policy proposals is the potential for more frequent eligibility renewals (e.g. twice per year) and stricter documentation or work requirements, especially for those in expansion populations.

Costs, Premiums, and Out-of-Pocket Expenses

Obamacare Costs

Marketplace coverage typically involves premiums, deductibles, copayments and coinsurance. Every plan must at least cover essential benefits.

Subsidies (premium tax credits) reduce the monthly cost you pay. The lower your income (within eligibility), the bigger the subsidy.

If you qualify for cost-sharing reductions, your out-of-pocket costs shrink further, but to receive those reductions you must enroll in a Silver plan.

Plans still carry deductibles and copays, though for those with modest incomes and subsidies, those amounts may be quite low.

Medicaid Costs

Medicaid generally imposes minimal costs on enrollees. Many have no premiums or very low premiums, especially below certain income levels (such as below 150% of the FPL).  ¹

States may impose nominal cost-sharing (copays, coinsurance), but by federal rule these must be restricted to keep healthcare affordable. Total out-of-pocket costs, including premiums and cost-sharing, are capped at 5% of family income in many expansion programs. 

The federal law limits imposing premiums and cost-sharing on low-income enrollees, to reduce barriers to care. 

Some states, through waiver programs, experiment with higher premiums or cost-sharing, but core protections remain in place for the most vulnerable. 

Benefits and Limitations of Each Program

Obamacare Strengths and Drawbacks

Marketplace plans offer wide provider networks, multiple tiers of coverage (Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Platinum), and flexibility in plan choice.

They’re valuable for those whose income exceeds Medicaid limits, yet still qualifies them for subsidies, offering a path to insured coverage without government-run care.

However, premiums (after subsidy) can still be burdensome for some, especially as enhanced subsidy programs expire. The Washington Post reports that as many as 22 million Americans face the loss of these enhanced premium tax credits. ²

Even subsidized individuals may face out-of-pocket costs through deductibles or coinsurance, especially if they require significant medical care.

Also, marketplace eligibility can be disrupted if your income fluctuates or exceeds certain thresholds, and you might lose coverage mid-year or owe subsidy repayment.

Medicaid Strengths and Drawbacks

One of Medicaid’s biggest advantages is affordability. Many qualify without paying premiums and with minimal costs. For low-income populations, Medicaid often represents the only realistic path to health coverage.

Medicaid may cover a broad range of services, some programs even include long-term care, dental, vision, behavioral health, and home- and community-based services that are not always covered under marketplace plans.

That said, provider availability can be a limitation, as some doctors or facilities don’t accept Medicaid. That can restrict access to specialists or high-demand services and lead to increased medical expenses.

Because states have flexibility, benefit levels, provider reimbursement rates, and eligibility rules vary across states. In states that declined Medicaid expansion, many adults remain uninsured, even at very low incomes.

Proposed legislative reforms (e.g., work requirements, eligibility checks, and cost-sharing changes) threaten to reduce access or change the balance of benefits.

Bottom Line

Medicaid and Obamacare overlap in intent, but function differently. Medicaid offers low-cost access to care for individuals with limited income, particularly in expansion states. Obamacare (through the marketplace) caters to individuals whose income is too high for Medicaid but still eligible for subsidies. Their eligibility, costs, benefits and enrollment rules vary widely, and policies are evolving.

Healthcare Planning Tips

• A financial advisor can help you estimate future healthcare expenses, optimize your use of HSAs or insurance, and incorporate healthcare costs into your retirement and estate plans. Finding a financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with vetted financial advisors who serve your area, and you can have a free introductory call with your advisor matches to decide which one you feel is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
• If eligible, contribute to a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Flexible Spending Account (FSA). HSAs, in particular, offer triple tax advantages: contributions, growth and withdrawals for qualified expenses are all tax-free.

Tanza Loudenback, a Certified Financial Planner™ (CFP®), provided the quotes used in this article. Please note that Tanza is not a participant in SmartAsset AMP, is not an employee of SmartAsset and has been compensated. The opinions voiced in the quote(s) are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations.

Photo credit: ©iStock.com/designer491, ©iStock.com/designer491, ©iStock.com/zimmytws